social reality of scholarly peer review

Peer-reviewed publications are currently the main currency for academic advancement.  Like fiat currencies  in general economic use, the value of editorial peer review appears to be largely in its value for economic transactions.  Consider, for example, a scholarly study published in 1982.  The authors created fictitious authors for twelve articles published in twelve highly regarded … Continue reading social reality of scholarly peer review

social constraints of social media

Getting persons to coalesce around a bigger project is not as simple as describing a bigger project.  An expressed desire to be like Wikipedia (but better) isn’t enough to get persons to contribute knowledge like they do for Wikipedia. Humans pursue their self-interests socially and create complex social dynamics. Because social relations involve complicated social … Continue reading social constraints of social media

so much for the Enlightenment

Jay Rosen on Wikileaks’ Afghanistan War Logs: 8. … “We tend to think: big revelations mean big reactions. But if the story is too big and crashes too many illusions, the exact opposite occurs.” My fear is that this will happen with the Afghanistan logs. Reaction will be unbearably lighter than we have a right … Continue reading so much for the Enlightenment